Your Trusted Insurance Partner
Why Choose Starkweather & Shepley Insurance Brokerage, Inc.
Clients turn to Starkweather & Shepley for a relationship-driven approach, responsive service, and thoughtful guidance across a wide range of insurance needs.
Clients choose Starkweather & Shepley for:
Client-focused service
Guidance for complex coverage considerations
A strong regional presence
Broad insurance experience
A team that values trust and quality service
Long-term client relationships
Service Offerings
Our team provides insurance services and benefit solutions for individuals and businesses with a focus on collaboration and long-term relationships. We work with clients to help them:
— Review coverage options for high-value assets
— Plan for complex personal and business risks
— Support employees and business operations
— Better understand their coverage choices
— Navigate change with experienced guidance
Business Insurance
Starkweather & Shepley Insurance works with businesses of many sizes and types. The team helps clients understand risk, review options, and choose coverage that supports long-term success. With the right support, business owners can make informed choices and move forward with more confidence.
Business insurance may include coverage considerations for:
- Property
- Employees
- Liability exposures
- Daily operations
- Long-term business planning
Insurance for Individuals & Families
The personal insurance division helps clients review coverage options, understand possible risks, and keep insurance aligned with changing needs.
Private client insurance is designed for individuals with more layered insurance needs. This may include higher-value homes, multiple residences, collections, lifestyle assets, broader liability concerns, or coverage needs across multiple locations.
Insurance for Individuals & Families may include coverage considerations for:
- High-value homes
- Vehicles
- Flood
- Valuable articles
- Travel insurance
Benefits Solutions
Employee benefits services are approached with clarity, responsiveness, and a strong understanding of employer priorities. Our team works with businesses to review options, compare plans, and make informed decisions that align with workforce needs and business goals.
Employee benefits planning may support:
- Employee well-being
- Hiring and retention efforts
- Long-term business planning
- Budget planning
- Workforce satisfaction
Our Mission
Starkweather & Shepley aims to provide products and services designed to meet client needs while maintaining a strong focus on trust and client relationships. We do that by providing our clients thoughtful counsel and relentless advocacy.
Our company’s stock is held in trust for the benefit of our clients and associates. We foster an empowering workplace environment for our employees and champion a strong commitment to our communities. Learn more about Starkweather & Shepley’s history and values.
A Reputation Built on Trust
We’ve built a strong reputation for service, professionalism, and responsiveness.
Our manufacturing facility has worked with Mike Prentiss for a number of years. Before we started doing buiness, our instance package was not up to par and needed help. Mike jumped in and needed help Mike jumped in and fine-tuned our coverage. His sense of urgency and knowledge of the insurance industry, particularly in the manufacturing area, are second to none. We could not be happier with the service, value and comfort knowing that we are in good hands.
Aviation Parts Manufacturer
I have had the pleasure of working with Mike Prentiss since 2020. His knowledge and expertise are second to none. Mike and the team at Starkweather & Shepley always respond quickly and are always there to help with my many questions and requests. I highly recommend them!
Callie Lee
Been using them for my insurance needs for 4 years and always there when you need them.
Joshua Evon
Office Locations
Starkweather & Shepley serves clients through offices in several states. This gives clients access to local support backed by the strength of a larger insurance brokerage.
The firm has office locations in:
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Starkweather & Shepley Insurance Brokerage, Inc. do?
Starkweather & Shepley is a full-service independent insurance brokerage firm. We offer private client insurance, business insurance, employee benefits services, and risk management support.
Starkweather & Shepley has built its reputation on putting clients first. Every relationship is founded on trust, transparency, and a commitment to understanding each client’s unique needs and goals.
Does Starkweather & Shepley work with high-net-worth clients?
Yes. Starkweather & Shepley provides personalized guidance and client-focused service for high-net-worth individuals and families. We work to coordinate property and casualty programs with broader financial or estate planning objectives.
What states does Starkweather & Shepley serve?
Starkweather & Shepley has locations in Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Florida. Through our partnership with Assurex Global, they serve clients and provide insurance solutions nationally across all 50 states, as well as internationally in more than 170 countries.
Does Starkweather & Shepley offer business insurance?
Yes. From promising start-ups to established enterprises, businesses depend on Starkweather & Shepley commercial insurance to protect them from loss. Our firm provides guidance on risk management and insurance options for businesses across various industries.
Does Starkweather & Shepley provide employee benefits solutions?
Yes. Our combination of practical experience and professional knowledge allows us to understand common challenges employers face and provide guidance on potential benefit options. We aim to offer data-informed, creative approaches to help clients make well-considered decisions that support both employees and organizational objectives.
Why choose an insurance brokerage like Starkweather & Shepley?
An insurance brokerage can help you understand your options, compare coverage, and make informed decisions based on your needs. Starkweather & Shepley stands out for its responsive service, relationship-driven approach, and long-term commitment to clients.
